※ Principle of ‘administrative appeal before litigation’
- Exceptions to the principle of ‘administrative appeal at discretion’ (principle of ‘administrative appeal before litigation’) are recognized in individual statutes:
· disciplinary actions against and other unfavorable dispositions in respect of public officials (Article 16 of the State Public Officials Act, Article 53 of the Educational Officials Act, and Article 20-2 of the Local Public Officials Act);
· dispositions under various tax statutes (Article 56 (2) of the Basic Act on National Taxes and Article 120 (2) of the Customs Act); provided that local taxes are excepted; and
· dispositions such as revocation or suspension of a driver’s license (Article 142 of the Road Traffic Act).
※ Exceptions to principle of ‘administrative appeal before litigation’
- Even where individual statutes adopt the principle of ‘administrative appeal before litigation’, an administrative lawsuit may be filed after filing an administrative appeal without first obtaining a ruling, if the following grounds exist (parts of Article 18 (2) of the Administrative Litigation Act, other than the Subparagraphs):
· where 60 days pass from the filing date of an administrative appeal without a ruling being made;
· where there is an urgent need to prevent a serious harm that would result from the execution of the disposition or the continuation of procedures;
· where there are grounds which would mean the administrative appellate body under the statutory provisions is unable to make a decision or ruling; or
· where other legitimate grounds exist.
- In addition, even in cases where the principle of ‘administrative appeal before litigation’ is adopted in other statutes, a lawsuit for revocation may be filed directly without going through an administrative appeal, on the following grounds (Article 18 (3) of the Administrative Litigation Act):
· where a dismissal ruling has already been made in an administrative appeal for the case of the same kind;
· where a ruling in an administrative appeal has already been made in respect of either a disposition that is interrelated due to its substance or a disposition that is being phased in for the same purpose;
· where, after the closing of pleadings in fact-finding proceedings, the administrative agency modifies the disposition that is being litigated and a lawsuit is filed in respect of that modified disposition; or
· where the administrative agency that has made the disposal has provided incorrect information that there is no need to go through an administrative appeal.